Gas vs Electric Stove

When setting up your kitchen, one thing to consider is the stove to be used. In this scenario, you have to choose between gas vs electric stove for your culinary cooking.

The consideration between gas or electric stove will include whether the stove is cost-effective, skills, availability, performance and more.

For instance, professional chefs mostly prefer gas flames due to their faster ignition and efficient cooking. For safety purposes, some people prefer electric stove over a gas stove.

There are other important factors to consider which I will point out in this post. The pros and cons of both stoves will be helpful for your selection.

Nowadays, there are hybrid/dual-fuel ranges that can utilize both gas and electricity. This article will focus on choosing a single style stove for the kitchen.

Also See: Best Cookware For High Heat Cooking And The Ones To Avoid

Difference Between Gas And Electric Stove Cooking

One major difference is the way the two stoves respond to temperature changes. For instance, The electric stoves respond slowly than gas stoves when adjusting the temperature lower or turning off.

The other main difference between gas vs electric stoves is the energy used to power the unit. Gas uses natural gas and liquid propane while electric stoves are powered by electricity.

Gas Stoves

The gas stoves are powered by using natural gas and liquid propane which requires a gas line to be installed. Cooking with gas offers faster preheating for faster cooking.

There are great advantages of using gas stoves and no unit doesn’t have some disadvantages. The following are the pros and cons of gas stoves.

Pros

  • Ignites quickly
  • Heats food faster
  • Burner cools faster
  • Less risk of burns after the burner is shut off
  • More durable and longer-lasting
  • May work during a power outage

 Cons

  • Gas leak and explosion are risks
  • Flame Stability
  • Harder to control low heat
  • Can be harder to clean
  • May have fewer additional features
  • More expensive to install

Electric Stoves

As the name suggests, electric stoves use electric energy to power the unit creating heat on the cooktop. Electricity is readily available everywhere that can influence the use of electric ranges.

The following are the pros and cons of electric stoves.

Pros

  • Works well at low temperatures
  • Many cooking options available
  • Easy to control the exact amount of heat
  • Less expensive to install
  • Easier to keep clean
  • The flat surface may act as storage
  • No risk of gas leaks

Cons

  • Not as durable or long-lasting
  • Risk of burn after the burner is turned off
  • Takes longer to heat up
  • Takes longer to cook food
  • Will not work during an outage

 GasElectric
Upfront Cost$500 - $3000$700 - $1500
Operating CostLow(30 min per day =$14/yr)Higher(30 min per day =$44)
SafetyRisks of leakageSafer
Heat Time10 - 15 minutes20 - 30 minutes
Cook StyleSlightly MoistVery Dry
InstallationGas Line RequiredOnly electric Socket

Gas vs Electric Stove: Comparison

Appearance

The gas and electric stoves come with different styles and a variety of designs. Both have several colors and finishes to fit different kitchen styles.

One major difference between the two is the appearance of the top cooking surface. In electric stoves, coils are used for heating purposes while for gas stoves, they have raised visible burners with rings for cookware placement.

Some models may feature extra features like a grill, warming drawers, a variety of colors, fans which may be different from each other.

Costs

The cost of an appliance is one of the important considerations and includes initial cost and operational costs.

For the upfront cost, electric stoves are cheaper than gas stoves. The reason for the cost is because gas stoves require gas line installation and this involves experts fee and materials.

The cost of operation over the period puts gas stoves to be cheaper over electric stoves. In most states, natural gas costs less than electricity.

Installation

In most areas, electricity is already installed which makes electric stoves easy to install by just plugging it in. Electric stoves on average require about 240 volts.

Installation of gas stoves requires a gas line for it to function. You will need an expert to install the gas line and do all the connections.

Depending on the area, the costs of gas line installation will differ. If the area has no gas line, the cost increases for you have it installed in your kitchen.

Ignition & Heating Time

The preheating time between gas and electric stoves is different. Gas stoves produce heat immediately after ignition that makes cooking faster and save you some time.

Just at fast the burner distributes heat, once the heat is put off, it also cools down faster.

Electric stoves take time before heating up causing a delay for some minutes. The coils also remain hot after shut off which can cause overcooking of food if left on the burner.

Pre heat time on a gas stove approximately takes 10 to 15 minutes while electric stoves take 20 to 30 minutes.

Cooking Options & Style

Electric stoves offer additional options like induction cooking which is now popular for cooking. The electric stove produces a steady heat regardless of the setting. It offers a dry baking experience for crisp and crunchy foods.

Gas stoves cook well at high temperatures and type of heat for different cooking results. Gas provides a moist heat that can prevent roasting of food, drying out or burning certain pots.

Heat Distribution

A perfect heat distribution occurs when there is room for the burner to transfer heat to the pot. Gas stoves have the flames heating the bottom of the pot or pan and also the sides.  This creates an even distribution of heat.

Electric coils apply direct heat to the locations of the pot or pan sitting on the coil. This can cause some spots to be cold with less heat the area of contact.

Overall, gas stoves distribute heat evenly providing a uniform heating cycle.

Cooking Times

The gas vs electric stove cooking times are slightly different because gas preheats faster than electricity. Electric stoves don’t preheat immediately which causes a delay in some minutes.

There are instances where gas may be faster to cook certain foods and other foods take longer than electric stoves.

Temperature control

Another major difference between gas and electric stoves is temperature control and settings. In terms of response to change in flame for gas stoves, they can respond quickly or less instantly.

The control of the flames on gas ranges is easy for the successful cooking of various meals.

Electric stoves do not respond as quickly when adjusting the temperatures which make the cooking of some dishes challenging.

Fuel Source & Energy Efficiency

The gas stoves may use natural gas or liquid propane as fuel supplied through gas lines. This source of fuel is inexpensive and that’s why the operational cost for gas stoves is cheaper.

Electric stoves use only electricity for power and models with induction options are found to be more energy efficient.

In an event of a power outage, newer models of gas stoves that rely on electricity ignition would not function. The older models of gas stoves require a match to ignite.

Also, the electric stove doesn’t work when there is a power outage.

Which is Healthier?

If you are concerned about the health aspect of using a gas stove or electric one, there are some health concerns about gas stoves.

Although gas stoves are convenient and better for cooking, they may cause indoor air pollution. A recent study has shown that cooking without ventilating causes nitrogen oxide formaldehyde and carbon monoxide pollution.

Using vent fans reduces the level of exposure to these chemicals but not completely.

On the other hand, electric stoves reduce indoor pollution as they release fewer pollution substances.

Note: Ensure to have the best ventilation hood to remove the irritants and gases out of the kitchen. No matter the stove you choose.

Maintenance & Cleaning

Gas stoves can be harder to clean because of the design of the burners and grate. Newer electric stoves come with flat cooktops like glass and ceramic that makes then easy to clean.

Cleaning both units it’s not hard but for comparison, the electric stove is easier to clean and maintain.

Durability

Gas ranges can last longer than electric stoves as the ignition parts don’t wear out easily. The electric stoves ignition parts wear out faster which makes gas stoves more durable.

Electric stoves with glass or ceramic top ranges may get damaged if not carefully used and maintained.

Safety

Both gas and electric stoves have dangers if not used properly following safety precautions.

Gas stoves that use gas lines can be dangerous if there is a leakage. This may lead to serious fire to burn down the house.

Electric ovens are safer compared to gas stoves. Electrical faults can cause some issues but the cases are fewer.

Cookware

Cooking with gas or electric stoves will require cookware which can handle different levels of heat. Some cookware cannot handle the heat on electric stoves therefore, careful selection of the stove should consider the cookware to be used.

Extra Features

Electric models have more features and options than gas stoves. The electric stoves may consist of fans, warming drawers, grills, interior lights, etc.

Gas stoves have less extra features included as many models may include only warming drawers.

Conclusion

The decision between gas vs electric stoves depends on the factors above. In my opinion, both can offer cooking tasks without much difference.

If cost is an issue, then considering the option with less operation cost, in the long run, would be great.

For environment caring people, electric ranges pose few to none pollution effects.

Baking lovers find electric ranges to be a better option for perfect baked foods.

Overall, modern gas and electric stoves offer great features and performance. If you are willing to pay more for a hybrid stove, you can experience both cooking methods in one appliance.

Further Reading:

  1. Ninja Foodi Grill Review – The Best Indoor Grill
  2. Best Gas Grill Under 150 [Top 6 Best & Inexpensive Gas Grills]
  3. Stainless Steel vs Copper Cookware
  4. 9 Best Range Hoods For Gas Stoves
  5. Is A Slow Cooker Worth It? Pros And Cons
  6. Instant Pot Duo Plus Review